After reading Catching Fire, I was amused to see that the criminals in Les Miserables pass messages in and out of prison, and across prison yards, encoded (or sometimes simply hidden) in bread. Eponine checks out the Rue Plumet house while everyone else is in jail, and reports back with a biscuit, indicating that it’s not worth the effort.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Tag: LesMiserables
If you can’t be with the one you love…?
Montparnasse and Éponine have something going on, though it’s not clear what.
Montparnasse escaped capture after the attempted robbery because he left early, “more in a mood to amuse himself with the daughter than play hired assassin for the father.” In a later chapter, he’s described as “perhaps [Thénardier’s] unofficial son-in-law.”
It’s not clear how far it goes, though he’s more interested than she is. (She clearly has a thing for Marius from the moment you first meet her as a teenager.) In any case, it’s odd that Hugo dances around this, considering how frank he is about, for instance, Fantine’s relationship with Tholomyes.
Mostly in
https://hyperborea.org/les-mis/book/lark/
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Grantaire is just along for the ride
At one point during the campaign to build up support for the revolution, Enjolras starts sending his lieutenants out to recruit various guilds and workers for their cause. He has one last group to recruit. He was thinking of sending Marius, but he doesn’t show up anymore. (He’s despondent over having caught a glimpse of the girl whose name he still doesn’t know after all this time, and realizing he’ll never see her again.)
Grantaire volunteers.
“But you don’t believe in anything?”
“I believe in you.” *bats eyelashes* (OK, no eyelashes).
Yeah, he’s desperate to prove himself, specifically to Enjolras. It’s never entirely clear whether it’s hero worship or a crush (though in the case of the latter, it’s not as if Hugo would have made it clear in the 1860s)
Or…maybe he’s not so eager. Enjolras checks up on him later, and he’s playing dominoes with the marble-workers he was supposed to recruit.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Thenardier: The Original 419 Scammer
When we meet the Thenardiers again in Paris, they’ve lost the inn, and M. Thenardier is running a series of scams begging for money through letters. He diversifies his identities, tactics and targets in the pitches. Today he’d claim to be a Nigerian prince in one letter and a lottery commissioner in another. But the letter begging his neighbor (a penniless student named Marius) for money is about as honest as it could be…except for his name, which he’s given as Jondrette.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Eponine and the Infinite Sadness
Eponine in the musical is sad, but seems to be mostly getting along as best as she can under the circumstances. In the book, though, the Thenardiers are dirt poor after they lose the inn. She’s malnourished, dressed in rags that don’t have a hope of keeping her warm even in the snow, has a husky voice like “a bronchitic old man,” is missing teeth, and is down to skin and bones. “A blend of fifty and fifteen.” When she first visits Marius, she hasn’t eaten in three days.
Hugo compares her, and girls like her, to “flowers dropped in the street which lie fading in the mud until a cartwheel comes to crush them.”
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Alias Undercover
It takes most of a year for Marius to learn Cosette’s name. Once while they’re stealing glances at each other in the park, Valjean drops his handkerchief by accident. It’s embroidered U.F. for Ultime Fauchelevent (his current alias). Marius finds it, believes it’s hers, and decides her name must be Ursula. Later, when he learns that her father’s name starts with a U, he’s despondent, because the one thing he thought he knew about her has been taken away from him.
Since identity is the one thing that Hugo seems to keep limited to POV, for hundreds of pages they’re referred to by Courfeyrac’s nicknames for the duo: Monsieur Leblanc (because of his hair) and Mademoisele Lanoire (because she usually wears black, or did when she was younger).
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)I did not see you there…
While the musical takes liberties in condensing a year of Marius and Cosette’s courtship into two days, there is precedent in the novel for love at first sight…or at least, love at first glance.
Marius notices Jean Valjean and Cosette frequenting the same park as him for over a year, but pays them no mind until he stops going for a while, then comes back and she’s hit puberty. Even then, he doesn’t really notice until one day Marius’ and Cosette’s eyes meet. *ZAP!*
Suddenly he’s very self-conscious. The next day, he starts wearing his best clothes when going to the park, making sure he gets seen by her, and then starts thinking, huh, maybe the gentleman might think I’m acting a little odd.
One day they walk by his bench, and she glances at him. He’s overcome…but also worried because his boots are dusty and he’s sure she must have noticed.
They steal glances at each other, flirting from a distance. Marius starts hiding behind trees and statues so that he and Cosette can see each other but Valjean can’t see him.
About this time Valjean starts getting suspicious and starts changing their routine to see if Marius will follow. Marius, being an idiot, does. Not long after, Valjean stops bringing Cosette to the park.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)To read aloud is to assure oneself that one is reading…
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)To read aloud is to assure oneself that one is reading, and there are persons who read very loudly indeed, as though positively proclaiming the fact.
he was not a royalist, a Bonapartist, a chartist, an Orleanist, or an anarchist — simply a book-ist
Like everyone else he had a label, since at that time nobody could live without one, but his ‘ism’ was of a non-committed kind: he was not a royalist, a Bonapartist, a chartist, an Orleanist, or an anarchist — simply a book-ist.
Victor Hugo’s description of Pere Mabeuf, a friend of Marius’
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Marius the convert
Marius is one of those people who throws himself whole-heartedly into his beliefs, especially when they reverse.
He grows up in a Restoration-friendly household that hates Napoleon, the Republic, and the Empire, but when he discovers they’ve lied about his father, who was a decorated soldier under Napoleon, he completely throws himself into supporting the Republic, to the extent that he embarrasses himself in front of his friends who, while they support the ideals of the Republic, aren’t too fond of Napoleon.
Later on he ties all his well-being to his hoped-for life with Cosette, going from the heights of happiness when they’re together to the depths of complete and utter despair when he fears he’ll never see her again.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Why, Mr. Hugo, is that sarcasm?
Anyone walking through the little town of Vernon in those days, and crossing the beautiful stone bridge which, let us hope, will soon be replaced by some hideous construction of cables and girders…
Why, Mr. Hugo, is that sarcasm?
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Turning points
Becoming Cosette’s surrogate father is as major a turning point for Valjean’s soul as the incident with the bishop. This doesn’t come through in the stage musical at all, but they made it central in the movie, and Victor Hugo flat-out compares the two epiphanies in the novel: The bishop taught him virtue, while Cosette taught him the meaning of love. Hugo even ponders whether Valjean’s no-good-deed-goes-unpunished experience would have sent him back into bitterness if he hadn’t met her.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)It was deliberate!
Jean Valjean in the book is very deliberate. He rarely takes a big action without looking at the situation and thinking it through. He spends all night and the next day trying to decide whether to reveal his identity, even after he reaches the courthouse. He spends an hour at the inn observing how the Thénardiers treat Cosette vs. their own children, intervening on her behalf several times. He contemplates the message on Cosette’s blotter and stares at Marius’ reply for along time before heading off to the barricade.
But when there’s an immediate threat to someone, he reacts instinctively: the cart, the mast, or Madame Thénardier threatening to beat Cosette. No hesitation.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)An Extra Wrinkle
Completely skipped by the musical: Jean Valjean is recaptured, tried for robbing the chimney-sweep boy after his release, and sent back to prison. He offers no defense (he did take the coin), even though the prosecution claims he committed armed robbery with accomplices, which gets him the death penalty (though the king commutes it to life in prison). What he really did was step on a coin and refuse to move his foot.
Not long after he’s sent back to prison, he saves the life of a crewman on a ship that’s in for repairs, then “falls” to his apparent death in the waters below. No body is found, but who could survive that?
Honestly, the whole sequence doesn’t add much that we don’t already know, though it does give him a little anonymity in that he’s presumed dead until Javert figures out that he isn’t, making it even more of a one-man crusade to recapture him.
It also sets up a nice parallel between Valjean’s escape and Javert’s suicide, which the musical picked up on by using the same song for Valjean breaking parole and Javert breaking down.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Thénardier at Waterloo
The one scene in the entire 45-page section on Waterloo that figures into any character’s story occurs at the very end, when Thénardier accidentally saves Marius’ father’s life. He was in a pile of dead bodies, and Thénardier pulled him out to better get at his stuff. The “body” wakes up. “You saved my life!” “Um, yes, I did!”
Years later, the dying Col. Pontmercy impresses upon his son that he must find and repay the great man who saved his life, leading to some difficult choices when Marius finds out just what kind of person Thénardier is.
This is also why you need to be careful when abridging. Yes, you can pick up the basics from Pontmercy’s letter…but he doesn’t know what Thénardier was really doing before he regained consciousness.
The year I read the book the first time, I was in high school, and one of my teachers was using an abridged version of Les Misérables in another of his classes. I caught a glimpse of a student’s character study of Thénardier. Because their edition left out Waterloo entirely, the later misrepresentation of his actions here was taken at face value. It significantly altered the character by giving him a noble past that he never actually had.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Fantine’s Delirium
One of those weird coincidences: I was reading about Fantine dying of consumption while my wife and two-year-old son were hacking away with probably the worst cold either of them had ever had. It was rather disturbing. Especially when you add in the fact that Fantine hasn’t seen Cosette in five years, and remembers her as a two-year-old.
Incidentally, Victor Hugo never actually names Fantine’s illness. But as an extended respiratory disease in the 1820s, tuberculosis is a good bet.
The sisters at the hospital are afraid that the shock of learning M. Madeleine has left town and will miss his daily visit will kill her. Instead she rallies, convinced that the only reason he could possibly have left town is to retrieve Cosette! And in her delirium, she does in fact sing her daughter a lullaby.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Who the heck am I?
On stage, Valjean’s debate over whether to reveal his identity takes a couple of minutes. In the book, it takes about 50 pages of small print, from the sleepless night at home through the long, complicated journey to the courthouse in another town, though the hour he spends in the courthouse before he finally makes up his mind.
His two driving principles: redeem his soul and conceal his identity – have come into conflict for the first time. (Well, not really the first time. There was the incident with the cart, but that was only a minor risk.)
To take the chance fate has offered him, he has to do nothing. To make things right for the falsely accused, he has to go to great lengths just to get to the trial on time. He keeps deciding not to turn himself in, but taking another step towards reaching Arles, just in case he changes his mind.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)Those who falter…
Javert is so angry at being overruled regarding Fantine that he reports M.Madeleine as being Jean Valjean even though he still has no proof. So when he’s told that the “real” Valjean has been found, he not only feels that he’s been insubordinate, but that he’s done so for the wrong reason, and must be made an example of. He insists on being dismissed — simply resigning isn’t enough, because that would be honorable — because of the one-slip-and-you’re-out philosophy summed up in “Stars.”
This figures years later, when he allows Valjean to go free and feels he’s again in conflict with superior authority. But how can you resign from God?
This is one of those bits that wasn’t in the stage musical, but was added to the movie. I didn’t like it the first time through the film, mainly because of the execution (sorry, Russel Crowe), but after rereading the book, I agree with adding it. Even if it didn’t come off as well as it could have.
On Tumblr (Re-Reading Les Mis)No Coincidences
Comment on PAD’s Coincidence in Fiction
I love the take on Les Miserables. I’ve been re-reading the book, and the coincidences are just astonishing.
Things like Cosette starting to give up on Marius and catching a glimpse of a soldier, who just happens to be Marius’ cousin. The Thenardiers’ younger sons are taken in by a former servant of Marius’ grandfather, then get lost and picked up by Gavroche.
My favorite is probably the point at which one of Thenardier’s associates decides to mug some random guy who turns out to be Jean Valjean, on the street outside Marius’ friend’s house, while Gavroche is watching from the bushes.
There actually is a part in the novel where Eponine is manipulating various groups of people. The question is, should that be worked into Valjean’s sister’s spy network? Or is she an opposing force? Hmm…
Note: same ground mostly covered in Padded and No Such Thing as Coincidence
Yes, I do believe there are more pages in front of that bookmark than behind.
Yes, I do believe there are more pages in front of that bookmark than behind. #reading #LesMiserables #books #bookmark